Viral Marketing

posted 02/16/08 by Rick Webb

This is an old article I wrote. But it’s good for now!
One of the questions people ask me most in this business (just after “Do you really have to charge me for that?” and “Can I see something tomorrow?) is “Can you make a viral component for this?” I always cringe when I hear it. Even now, after all this time, the phrase “viral marketing” seems really cheesy. Hasn’t marketing always been based on word of mouth? Do we have to give it a disease-riddled name just because the medium has changed? My protestations aside, the term has stuck, and for better or worse, we at the Barbarian Group have done a fair amount of it. My coworkers and I always have a pretty good idea, before we even finish, whether it would fly or not. We’ve noticed a few consistent factors, and I’ve boiled them down to 5 handy rules on viral marketing:

  1. Viral Marketing is neither e-cards, nor is it an add-on. All too often potential clients want to cover all the bases with one interactive initiative. They want to build what they think is an robust site, and then simply tack on some e-cards to it, to give it a viral component. Always remember: there has to be a compelling reason for the user to send around a link or a site: The ability for a user to spread the word does not equate with a reason for him/her to bother.
  2. Accept that you may not be able to control your brand completely with good viral marketing. “Branding” has been so dominant in advertising theory for so long now, we often forget that it’s just one theory. A good one, to be sure, but it has its limits. Viral Marketing cannot necessarily be branded. I’ve found it’s best to be 100% up-front about this with your client, from the beginning. The last thing you want to have happen is to develop an amazingly funny, viral video and have the client insist that their logo and tagline end it. Your target market is amazingly media savvy – that’s why you’re trying to get to them with viral marketing and not a print ad, right? – and they will resenting any overt manipulation. In general, viral marketing works because it conveys the sense that a company is about more than money and branding, that it has the same sense of fun and the same worldview as its customers. This worldview is not a corporate, branded one.
  3. Viral Marketing is especially susceptible to too many cooks in the kitchen. In retrospect, this is the single biggest stumbling block for good viral marketing. A great idea is born, and between the great idea and the public finally experiencing it, there are any number of intermediate stages of approval – an agency creative, his/her superior, the client, the client’s boss, the president of the client company and, if you’re uniquely unlucky, there’s a parent company with a whole new batch of stakeholders. When people ask us “why did such-and-such campaign get so successful?”, 9 times out of 10, it’s because no one was paying attention to us. Brand managers were on vacation, or they didn’t care about interactive. When that’s not an option, remember that the ability to massage your work unfettered through these approvals, along with the ability to secretly skip over them, is as important as a good idea when it comes to viral marketing.
  4. Trust your instincts, but do a little market testing. If you don’t think it’s funny, no one else will either. Listen to yourself as you work on the campaign. You’ll know, deep down, if it’s going to work or not. If you have doubts, don’t ignore them. And don’t send something out in the world if you don’t genuinely think it will be effective. That being said, the echo chamber is a real risk. Find some people in the demographic, and pitch the idea to them. If the bulk of them don’t laugh right away, it might be time to head back to the drawing board.
  5. Sometimes, even the best creative needs a little push. It’s easy to get dogmatic about viral marketing and say “if it’s good, it’ll take right off.” But the internet is a big place, and unless you really know how to work it and drive traffic immediately, it can be hard to get people to notice your endeavors. We’ve had campaigns sit on the web for months before they took off, and by then it can be too late. Consider a small banner campaign to kick things off, or, better yet, think about hiring a firm to “seed” the campaign (I know, viral seeding. Ick). A relatively small investment here can mean the difference between a lost investment or a fantastic ROI.

  6. Another insight, from a letter to AdAge I wrote last year:
    Mass marketing works consistently, viral marketing fails or works spectacularly. The allure of viral marketing is not that it works better, it’s that it might work much better, for a lot less. The downside, of course, is that viral marketing might not work at all: we, as marketers, don’t “make virals,” we make things that sometimes “go viral.”

    It’s probably time that brands start thinking of viral marketing as one component of your marketing: one that might provide massive additional benefits for a small amount of money, but then again, might not. Win some, lose some. But over time, with a consistent, methodical approach to it, the extra cost will pay for itself over a broad spectrum of endeavors. Even the most cautious investor still likes to play a hot stock tip, just not with their 401k.

Here are some recent posts from our employees about Viral Marketing:

Interactive Advertising and Media Placement Companies don't mix.

UPDATE: So apparently it wasn’t the MTA, but our Media Placement Company who made the call to strike the Hello Health ads. So, deepest of apologies, MTA, for being under the mistaken impression that you were bad guy on this one. Tell you what? I’ll buy an unlimited Metrocard and promptly lose it as penance.

Monster Viral

Ok, so who’ll cop to it? Is it for Silent Hill V? Is it for Cloverfield 2? C’mon, ad world, which one of you is trying to pull one over on us this time?
(As an aside, I find it truly depressing that I can’t look at something like this without having a knee-jerk “it’s an ad for something” reaction. See guys? This is why we advise against hoaxism. It just leaves your customers feeling…duped.)

Celebrity Candy

The M&Ms Campaign spearheaded by BBDO continues to impress. The latest iteration I particularly like are the celebrity print ads. Bobby Flay, Indiana Jones, Kyle Busch. I hope they continue because it can become the next big iconic print campaign, like the milk mustache or Absolut Vodka.
A good sign is the latest iteration by Latinworks, Austin TX (good friends of mine Manny Flores, Alex Ruelas are the founders) featuring Wilmer Valderrama and discussed in the NYT. Ok, I wish it was someone with a bit more street cred like Carlos Santana but hey, it’s gotta start somewhere.
All of this is exciting, of course, because we were there at the beginning. We created becomeanmm with BBDO back in early 2007 and users started creating their own celebrity M&Ms, like The Donald to the left. Awesome.

an unexpected turn for the awesome.

so today explosions and boobs guy and i were talking about awesome commercials that happened to become hilarious viral hits on youtube, milkandcookies, ebaumsworld, etc. examples include wet pets, the hawaii chair, the bizarre sharper image beamz system, and of course the unintentionally filthy mr. bucket theme song (which i won’t link because you might think i’m some sort of monster).
somewhere along the way, i got to see an excellent cadbury (like the buck buck chocolate cadbury) ad featuring a gorilla playing drums.
seriously. a gorilla playing drums, advertising chocolate in theory, but really building a brand presence. it’s a great ad, i’m surprised i hadn’t seen it sooner.
but what i find most intriguing about it, is that they have a page of remixes. remixes! of the gorilla playing drums! for chocolate! the internet is AWESOME.
and then i find myself thinking “why didn’t i think of that?”
check the original ad below:

effective advertising.

really, i could get behind more ads if they had a jaunty personality like sammy stephens and an awesome song to go with it.
this is totally for nick. totally.
edit: oh man, even better? pet shop remix!

Not so sure about The Internet

Hilarious debate among Hollywood types at last week’s Digital Upfront about whether or not there’s been an internet video “hit” yet. Ha. Really? How about the fact that Time magazine chose user generated video content as their person of the year in 2006?
And, I guess, I should also mention our very own Subservient Chicken which has had more than 200 million unique visitors worldwide, twice the size of this year’s Super Bowl?
What is Hollywood talking about? Oh wait, they are waiting for THEIR first hit. I see…

CNN Shirts!

Over the past few months we have been hard at work with one of our zanier ideas yet…a celebration of sorts, with our friends over at CNN.
And not just any celebration of course—this one is all about the news—and pretty much all the headlines that are fit to print… on a T-shirt.
We got really excited when CNN asked us to help them help people uncover the newly reorganized and video rich CNN.com. They came to us looking for a fun way to get the word out and we decided what better way to turn “I just saw it on CNN.com” into a phenomenon than on a T-shirt.
The premise is simple- we added a tiny little T-shirt icon next to the headlines on the front page. Click on the T-shirt and you are taken through a seamless shirt ordering experience where you can have your favorite headline turned into a shirt (gray, white or the currently most popular black) unique to you with a custom time-stamp—all for just $19.99 including shipping!
Some of our favorites so far have included: “Weird fish leave sea, spawn on beach,” “Prince drops copter in galpal’s yard”
Sound fun? Sound crazy? Don’t believe us? Check it out for yourself and help get the word out. There will be new shirts on cnn.com every day. Heck you might even find a headline you can’t live without too!

Did Someone Order a Beer Cannon?

N.B. This post was from the last version of our site

You might be aware of the fact that beer can be used as a gateway to good times, but did you know that it can also be used to blow stuff up? It can. And that's why we've created the Milwaukee's Best Light Beer Cannon with our dear friends at Mother. Go to the site and see videos of beer and other things getting shot out of a cannon at the worst stuff ever. You know you want to find out who walks away the victor in the battle of Milwaukee's Best Light vs. The Ceramic Kitten. Hint: Beer always wins.