Social Networking and Community

posted 02/23/08 by Rick Webb

Oh man. Just when you thought you were getting a handle on this whole internet thing. Just when internet video started to… like.. you know, become something you could get your head around. Just when internet video became popular enough that you could really start to GET this internet thing. Lower res? 2-3 minutes long? Lower production values? Get it. Check. Priced accordingly. Banners are like billboards, viral videos are like infomercials. I get it now. Oh, if only it were that simple. Sadly, things keep on changing.

The Super Simple Overview

Social Networking. Community. Social Media. We’re not super big fans of the term “social media,” but.. it’s all related, we suppose (as an aside, we’re not a big fan of the term “earned media,” but that is the subject of some whole future blog post.
One day, somewhere around 2004 or so, people started friending each other on the internet. Friendster first, then MySpace, then Facebook, and a million others along the way (personally, we like to give props to Livejournal, which has never gotten its due as groundbreaking in this space). Friending each other on the internet. What did that mean? Why is that important?
I think the simplest way to look at it is through the prism of Viral Marketing. Viral marketing spreads a marketing message through a friend network – people find something humorous, so they pass on a link to someone else to share it with a friend, so that they can have a shared, common experience. Before social networking, for most people, this was maybe an email, or an IM to someone. Maybe they’d email it to two or three people. But as they “friended up” with more and more people on the internet, tools were developed to quickly, easily propagate that message (or “meme”) to many people at once.
And not only that, other people could see this happening, and measure the rate at which this happens. All sorts of interesting things come out of this. Whole maths and measurements about viral propagation speeds and online mavens and such fascinating stuff: what message move fastest? What sorts of people move the most messages? Who do people listen to the most?
There are a million ways to view this. Measuring the social graph. Niche and subcultural communities. Interconnected functionality (via Web 2.0 philosophies). There are a myriad of opinions on what value this provides to a brand. Whether it can be unlocked. Whether it’s worth advertising against. There’s a lot of money out there being placed on a lot of big bets. Will Facebook be worth its $10 billion valuation? Was Myspace worth $500 million? I mocked it at the time and in most ways, I was proven wrong, but I still maintain Rupert could have given me a tenth of that and I would have built a better MySpace, and Facebook has more than proven this viewpoint as at least viable.
We’re not especially in the game of placing the big entrepreneurial bets on developing communities that strive to aggregate large communities so they’re worth some money to the IACs of the world. We do, however, have a proven track record of aggregating audiences, and so of course we constantly endeavor to bring these skills to new areas that are of interest to marketing and advertising, and this, indeed, is one of those areas. We dabble, of course, on the community-as-startup side, but really, more than anything, we look for other ways to unlock value for our clients through social networking and community.
This area (and its cousin, user-generated content, UGC) is a scary area for marketers. Last year’s traditional party line about UGC and advertising was that marketers were nervous advertising against UGC because they didn’t know what sort of content they would be advertising next to. No one wants to put an ad next to a hate group’s fan page. I’ve always thought that inevitably these concerns would diminish for advertisers. The cynic in my notes that Hustler Magazine has no shortage of advertisers, and the naive optimistic citizen in me could have sworn there was supposed to be some separation between the editorial staff and the advertising staff at magazines, so this should have been a big problem in the magazine world too, right? But I think my friend Patty Mitchell put it best: “you’re in a parking lot, having a fight with your girlfriend, and you’re breaking up. And over at the side of the parking lot is a billboard for Verizon. Do you blame Verizon for your breakup? No. Life happens. And advertising is there. We’re used to it.” My views are probably optimistic, of course, as the recent acknowledgments from Google about difficulties advertising against Myspace and Youtube suggest. Still, though, if I were in the media planning business, I’d recommend you take advantage of other brands’ nervousness and reap the benefits of low CPMs. But, then again, I am not in the media planning business.
Yeah, so it’s scary. Where we excel is making it just a little bit less scary. Harnessing UGC for your brand, without potentially exposing it to damaging messages – such as our work on the M&Ms world. Or aggregating a community around a holistic set of principles and beliefs, and offering them utility and value, such as the branded utility + community approach we take with Kashi.com. Or finding a way for people to feel like they’re part of a community, without them going and being able to upload a bunch of porn, like our work for the Webby Awards and the People’s Choice awards.
We constantly look for ways, through our marketing R&D prism, to incrementally improve the social networking and community landscape for our clients. It’s an ongoing process, and one in which you’ll see a lot of activity from us in the coming months.

Here are some recent posts from our employees about Social Networking and Community:

Interactive Interactive Ads

Woah! Facebook’s new comments gone wild philosophy recently extended to ads! That’s kinda dope.

Death of Scrabulous

Much has been written about the Death of Scrabulous today, but none echo my sentiments as much as this post on Mashable.
Honestly. Do you know how difficult it is to build a passionate, dedicated and active user base of a half-million people? I understand you need to protect your brand and IP rights, but this isn’t exactly going to come out in Hasbro’s favor at the end of the day.
Why not just buy those guys out and re-skin the product? Turn it into an ad-revenue machine?

I love the internet

It’s taken about five years, but FINALLY I am back in touch with all the people who I missed from my past. Elementary school friends, even! I used to sneak off campus for lunch in 8th grade and smoke cigarettes at BC’s house. She just found me on myspace last week. Yay social networking!

We Prefer Public Parks

Social networks are, simply, networks for socializing. A helpful utility to keep in touch with friends on your own time and on their own time. No need to be in the same room at the same time, on the phone at the same time, etc. Of course, everyone knows this. We all use them all the time. And I do mean “them.” As in, a lot of them. Facebook. LinkedIn. MySpace. Bebo. Flixster. Gather. Last.fm. Plaxo. Twitter. Rock.com…and new ones are built every day.
I wish there one.
I guess Facebook is still my first check point. I wonder if it will stay that way.
Great article by Peter Whoriskey in the Washington Post discussing Google’s Friend Connect
and Facebook’s decision to forbid its members from signing in to websites using this new service from Google, effectively creating yet another confined and specific group of friends, aka another “walled garden.” Yikes. I can’t deal with another subset of friends.
I know it’s about money and keeping an audience but I think if sites like Facebook stop being open platforms then we’ll take our socializing elsewhere. I prefer a public park to a walled garden.

More Brands Are Experimenting With Twitter

Do you use Twitter? I guess you could say I am a fair weather friend. It’s tough at times for me to keep a steady stream of fresh blog posts going, never mind updating Twitter with every move, thought, inspiration, etc. But I do love the concept – I dabble from time to time – and I have a serious respect for what it has done to ignite conversation. I do attempt to read the tweets of the people I follow, primarily those in the industry, as there’s a lot to learn from their daily ramblings. But what I find most inspiring and exciting, is that more and more brands are starting to embrace Twitter as part of their experimentations with social media! There are two in particular I have decided to follow:
First up, Tablet Hotels, a stellar online resource for finding the the most unique, non-commercialized, hidden gems of hotels, globally. I’ve stayed at a couple, and they rock. There’s a lot of other cool bells and whistles on the site too that you should check out, but that’s for a separate post. So, the guys over at Tablet Hotels, who I just discovered are former agency guys so this now makes more sense to me, have started to use Twitter recently to distribute some great information, such as deals at hotels, new hotels added to their exclusive list, newsletter announcements, etc. I’d be curious to learn if they have seen an increase in site visits, conversions, etc. since incorporating Twitter into their digital marketing strategy. I would be willing to bet they have.
Next up, one of my favorite brands, Zappos. And aside from the fact that I have a total shoe addiction and shoes in general just make me elated, I really think Zappos is a top-notch brand run buy some authentic and pretty amazing people. Remember this story? Anyway, Tony, the CEO of Zappos, is quite the Twitterer. I think he is a junkie (positive twist to that comment); check out Zappos’ new biz cards. Tony’s strategy is a little different than Tablet Hotels’. He has chosen to use Twitter as a vehicle to provide a behind the scenes look into the brand from his perspective, and a glimpse at his life as the CEO and the lives of the employees of probably the most effective online shoe sales business around. He also encourages his employees to use Twitter – 250+ of them are – and there’s even a Beginner’s Quick Start Guide and Tutorial to Using Twitter that he assembled.
I love emerging media, and following the trends, and I just think it’s so great to see brands, and employees of those brands, leveraging some of the simplest social media tools to connect with one another internally, engage their users, and reach their audience in a new way with a different content angle. If you follow any brands on Twitter, let me know how they are using the tool and your thoughts on their strategies.

Blogging 101

I have been an avid and experimental blogger now for over 2 years, and recently friends, family, and complete strangers have approached me asking for tips and advice on how to get started. So, in the spirit of being a newbie (I’m going on week four at TBG!), I decided perhaps it’s time to share some of my ideas on how individuals should start to think about blogging and join the community. Many of these points may seem rudimentary and pronounced to us folks in the digital marketing industry, but to those who are not, I understand blogging can be a pretty intimidating endeavor. So, here are a few steps that may help to guide newcomers navigating through the blogosphere:
Familiarize and Educate
Like any other new life trial, the first step individuals interested in blogging should take is to get familiar with exactly what a blog is and its role on the internet. Sure, anyone can hit-up Wikipedia and find that a “blog (an abridgment of the term web log) is a website, usually maintained by an individual, with regular entries of commentary, descriptions of events, or other material such as graphics or video.” But that sounds so text book, and most importantly, very one-way, eh? The absolute most important function of a blog from my perspective is that it is, in most cases, not just a website and should not be treated as a repository for forcing a message, but rather it is a two-way communication tool, a very Web 2.0 concept. No longer are people and brands allowed to market via “shouting” their message at consumers (one-way); but now consumers and individuals interested in the same or parallel topics can take part in the conversation by commenting on a post, or writing a post on their own blog to communicate a message or idea to spark the conversation. It is this two-way conversation that I think is the most powerful aspect of blogging and a critical piece to grasp when dabbling with blogging, even on the individual level.
Experiment and Participate
Next up, get out there and start participating in the conversation (sorry to sound very Joseph Jaffe but it is true!). Bloggers-to-be should add a few RSS feeds of their favorite blogs to their feed aggregator (mine is Netvibes), start reading on a regular basis, and start commenting. Take that one step further, and start an experimental blog just to get your feet wet using one of the many friendly and easy to use platforms out there that are available at little or not cost, such as TypePad, Blogger, and Wordpress this is what I did to experiment with blogging (I am on my 3rd personal blog!), and there are a some valuable lessons that I learned – which may be obvious – but are excellent rules of thumb for newbies:

  • Be transparent and honest. If not, readers are going to see right through you, and either stop reading, or worse, call you out on it

  • Do research before writing. Nothing worse than presenting your POV based on mis-information or hearsay

  • Be yourself, write in your own voice

  • Encourage people to comment and provide their opinion on a given topic

  • Don’t spend hours writing and re-writing posts. Blog entries don’t have to be perfect

Evaluate
Once educated and actively participating, if still interested in blogging, it’s important to see what other people are saying about you or your brand/company before you officially launch your blog, and evaluate whether or not it makes sense to start a blog. Set up Google Alerts for your name or brand, and run a search on Technorati or the like. If there’s anything negative circulating in the blogosphere, you need to be prepared. Blogging is risky at times, as people are going to inevitably disagree with you and rebut your ideas, conversations may get heated, and you need to have thick skin from time to time. And finally, if you are still sold on blogging, make sure you define the goals and objectives of your blog, stick to ‘em, and remember to post often to keep people engaged.
So again, here at TBG it’s clear that everyone “gets” how to blog, as I have watched all my colleagues get involved and this space grow exponentially over the last few days since the site launch; but, to all those blog-curious folks out there, it can be intimidating. Take a deep breath and give it a shot!

Too Many Words and Not Enough Pictures

So I was checking out the hubub over at adweek on our new site. We were winning the vote earlier on, but I’ll let Grey have their way. That’s cool. Luckily other reviews have been more positive.
It’s interesting, though. I note two threads in those comments: first, that we were known as a Flash house, so why do we have such a “boring” site? And secondly, “too many words!” Who has time to read all those words? I felt a brief surge of panic that I always feel when hit with a little criticism, but I figured hey! We have a site where we have to write all the time now! I may as well write out our thinking on the matter.

My brand is a round peg and Facebook is a square hole

The one thing I have come across in the past 6 months of watching brands try to fit themselves into the Facebook mega-trend is that – if you can, make a game, do it, do it, do it. Everyone likes…